12 Dog Breeds That Often End Up Back In Shelters

Adopting a dog can be one of life’s most rewarding experiences, but it also comes with serious responsibilities. Unfortunately, not all adoptions result in forever homes. Every year, thousands of dogs are returned to shelters, often because their new families were unprepared for the breed’s specific needs. Certain dog breeds are more likely to be surrendered due to behavioral issues, high energy levels, grooming demands, or misunderstandings about their temperament.

In this blog, we explore 12 dog breeds that often end up back in shelters, despite their many lovable qualities. Knowing which breeds commonly face this fate can help potential adopters make more informed, compassionate choices. Whether you’re considering adoption or just want to better understand canine behavior, this list highlights the importance of research, training, and commitment when bringing a dog into your home. Choosing the right breed can mean the difference between a happy home and a heartbreaking return.

Pit Bull Terrier

One breed of dog that you can often find in shelters is the Pit Bull Terrier. People often get the wrong idea about these dogs because of how strong they look and how aggressive they are portrayed in the media. A lot of people who want to get them don’t fully understand how much energy they have or how much training and education they need. If these dogs don’t get enough exercise and excitement, they might have behavior problems that force owners to give up the dogs.

Some places have laws that say pit bull owners can’t live in certain places, which makes it harder for people to keep their dogs. Because of their strong personalities, these dogs need people with a lot of experience. If they don’t have this, they often end up back in shelters. To help these dogs stay in their forever homes, people need to learn how to be good dog owners.

Labrador Retriever

Labrador Retrievers are the most popular dog breed in the United States, but many of them end up in shelters. People often get Labs as pets because they think they will be calm and good with kids, but they don’t realize how active they can get, especially when they are young. Labradors need to be given lots of care, exercise, and mental activity. If they don’t get this, they might act out or get too hyper, which can be too much for first-time owners.

Labs can also become overweight and have other health problems if they are not properly cared for, which makes things harder for families who aren’t ready. Not enough people know how big and strong Labs can get, which makes them harder to handle. Even nice dogs are sometimes sent back to shelters when people’s hopes don’t match up with reality.

German Shepherd

Even though German Shepherds are smart, loyal, and protective, they often end up back in shelters because they are so needy. They are working dogs that need to be trained regularly, get along with other dogs, and have a job to do. If they don’t have these, they might get nervous, angry, or harmful. A lot of people get Shepherds because they look good or have a good image, but they don’t realize how much time and work it takes to train them properly.

They aren’t the best choice for families who don’t do much or for people who have never owned a dog before. Behavior problems are often caused by not getting enough exercise and rules. People or families who are busy and can commit to organized activities and regular training are the best fit for these dogs.

Chihuahua

Chihuahuas are small dogs with big personalities, and people who try to adopt them often end up taking them back to shelters. Chihuahuas are small, so many people think they are easy to take care of. However, they can be demanding, protective, and stubborn. They tend to make strong bonds with one person, so kids or other pets might not get along with them. They can get snappy or mean if they don’t get to know other people.

Some dog owners aren’t ready for how hyperactive they are and how much they bark. Also, because they are fragile, they shouldn’t be handled roughly, which happens a lot in homes with young children. These things make it more likely for Chihuahuas to be thrown away.

Dalmatian

Dalmatians are beautiful dogs, but people often accept them without thinking twice. A lot of people don’t know this, but Dalmatians are active, independent, and sometimes stubborn. They were bred to be carriage dogs, so they like being active and having a routine. If they don’t get enough exercise, they can develop behavior problems like being harmful or angry. Dalmatians can also go deaf, which means they need more training and care.

Their strong will and need for care can be too much for people who aren’t ready for them. Because of these problems, a lot of Dalmatians are thrown away when they need too much care, especially if the choice to accept them was based only on how they look.

Jack Russell Terrier

Jack Russell Terriers are small dogs that have a lot of drive and energy. They were originally bred to hunt, so they need to be active and mentally stimulated all the time. They often act out and cause damage when their needs aren’t met. A lot of people buy them because they are small, but they don’t realize how hard they are to take care of. They are also very smart and can trick people who aren’t paying attention, which can cause behavior problems.

Most of the time, Jack Russells don’t get along with other pets, especially small ones. If you don’t train them right, they can be mean, stubborn, and protective. People who have never had a dog before are often surprised by these traits, which is why the dogs end up back in shelters.

Siberian Husky

Many people get Siberian Huskies because they are pretty and active, but they don’t know what kind of dog they really are. They are independent and stubborn, and because they were bred to pull sleds in cold weather, they have a lot of energy. Huskies need a lot of mental and physical activity. If you leave them alone for too long, they might try to run or do something bad.

Their stubbornness can make teaching them hard, especially for people who have never owned a dog before. Also, their thick coat sheds a lot, which can be hard for people who aren’t ready for the cleaning needs. When people realize how much work it is to take care of a Husky, many decide they can’t do it, which leads to a high return rate.

Beagle

People love beagles because they have cute looks and are friendly, but they are not as easy to take care of as many people think. As scent dogs, they love to follow smells and will often ignore orders if a smell interests them. Because they have a strong desire to hunt, they can be hard to control if you don’t train them well and keep their outdoor places safe.

Beagles also make a lot of noise and can howl or bark too much if they are not excited, which can be a problem in cities. When they are left alone, their high energy and need for company can make them act in bad ways. Families often don’t realize how much time and work it takes, which causes them to give up.

Boxer

Boxers are friendly and playful, but their high energy and strong personalities can be too much for some families to handle. To keep them from getting bored and acting out, they need to move and think about new things every day. They are also known for being protective, which can turn into aggression or nervousness around people if they are not socialized properly.

A lot of people get Boxers because they look good or because they are known to be good with kids, but they are surprised by how loud and strong they are. Boxers need to be trained and consistently rewarded. If they don’t, they can become too much to handle, which means they end up back in shelters a lot.

Cocker Spaniel

People often think of cocker spaniels as sweet and loving pets, but they need more care than most people think. Their long, flowing coats need to be brushed often to keep them from getting matted and infected. Also, they often get ear infections that need ongoing care.

In addition to needing regular grooming, Cocker Spaniels can be sensitive and show behavior problems like aggression or separation anxiety if they are not educated and taught properly. Some may snap if they are scared or are treated badly. People who adopt them because they look cute often find it too hard to take care of them and deal with their behavior problems, so a lot of them are returned.

Australian Shepherd

Australian Shepherds are smart, active, and loyal, but their desires to work as working dogs can make them hard for most people to train as pets. They were bred to group animals, but they often try to do the same thing with kids, other pets, or even people, which can be dangerous in the home. They need hours of mental and physical activity every day to stay calm and happy.

If they don’t get this, they might act out, be nervous, or be harmful. People who have never had a dog before often don’t realize how demanding these dogs are. Because they are smart, they get bored quickly if they aren’t constantly pushed. Australian Shepherds are often given up when these needs aren’t met.

American Bulldog

American Bulldogs are big, strong dogs that need owners who are sure of themselves and have a lot of dog experience. They are loyal and watch out for you, but they can also be stubborn and defensive. A lot of people get them because they look tough, but they don’t realize how much work it is to train and socialize such a strong breed. They need to be taught in a strong, regular way and be exposed to different people and places early on.

If you don’t handle them properly, they might become violent or impossible to control. Health problems like hip dysplasia and skin issues can also get expensive, which can make people give up. Because of these problems, American Bulldogs are often sent back to shelters when it gets too hard to take care of them.

Bottom Line

While all dogs deserve a loving home, some breeds are returned to shelters more often due to unmet expectations, lack of training, or high care demands. Understanding the challenges of these 12 breeds can help prevent heartbreak for both owners and pets. If you’re considering adoption, take time to learn about each breed’s personality, energy level, and needs. Proper research and preparation are essential for creating a lasting bond with your pet. By choosing a breed that fits your lifestyle, you can reduce the chances of surrender and give a dog the forever home it truly deserves.

FAQs